Skip to main content

TEACHER CENTRIC AND STUDENT CENTRIC EDUCATION - A COMPARISON


A dichotomy is a contrast between two things. When there are two ideas, especially two opposed ideas — like war and peace, or love and hate — you have a dichotomy.

Student centric and teacher centric classroom is not a dichotomy. Why?

Let me tell you. Even if their tastes differ significantly from those of their friends, students can choose the learning strategies that best suit them when they are aligned with a student-centered approach to learning. Kevin M. Wong notes in a recent paper in Educational Technology Research and Development that regardless of the strategies employed to promote student-centered education, the end effect frequently involves a greater sense of student agency in the classroom.

In light of this, student- and teacher-centered learning are not necessarily mutually exclusive. Both of these educational strategies can help teachers create compelling learning experiences that are catered to the specific needs of their students by providing them with a wide variety of teaching strategies to select from.

Each approach—teacher-centered and student-centered—has benefits and drawbacks of its own. Recently, student-centered education has gained popularity among teachers. However, given that teacher-centered education is a successful teaching approach in a variety of subject areas, we cannot ignore it. I would propose combining these approaches to come up with a more successful plan. where the pupils can be reprimanded quietly while yet working as a group. Simply try several approaches until you find the one that works best for you and your kids because you are the person who knows them best. Just be sure you incorporate the pupils and keep them interested. Use a balanced educational environment, please.

Before I wrap up the lecture, let me briefly review our discussion on teacher-centered and student-centered education.

When learning is oriented on the teacher, students are completely focused on the teachers. Students listen as the teacher speaks. Here, the problem is, collaboration is discouraged among the students as they work alone in activities if there are any. There is no space for the students to communicate or interact with their classmates.

Pros of Teacher-Centric Classroom:-

No doubt, there will be a well-organized classroom. You're much disciplined. Students are quite quiet. Students are capable of making their own decisions and becoming autonomous since they are taught in this manner, which is no doubt, a good thing. The teacher can cover every topic, never missing one, and is self-satisfied that they have finished their lectures.

Cons of Teacher-Centric Classroom:-

Students may feel bored and may miss some crucial topics if collaboration with other students is lacking. Clearly, this approach doesn't allow students to express themselves and sometimes prohibits them from asking questions. Lateral thinking is often discouraged, and students are forced to study in the manner that only how the teacher has taught them. They are afraid of deviating from any approach because they believe either they might go wrong, or it would result in punishment.

Unlike in the teacher-centric case, the focus in Student-centered method, the instruction is shared by both students and teachers. Meaning to say that, the students and teachers interact equally rather than solely listening to the teacher. Here students are encouraged to work in groups and learn to collaborate and communicate with one another.

Pros of Student-Centric Classroom:-

Group work teaches students crucial communicative and collaborative skills; students can talk, ask questions, and finish projects independently. When students can freely communicate with one another and participate actively, they will be more interested in learning activities.

Cons of Student-Centric-Classroom:-

Since students are talking, classrooms may frequently be chaotic or boisterous. When students are working on different stages of the same project, teachers may be required to try to manage all of the students' efforts at simultaneously. Also, some pupils may miss crucial information since the teacher doesn't always instruct everyone at once. Because some students prefer to work alone, group projects might be challenging.

If someone challenges you and claims that the teacher-centric approach is the best one, it shows they are only considering the advantages of the approach and haven't considered its drawbacks. However, it has been discovered that more teachers have shifted towards a student-centered approach in recent years, where teachers are seen more as facilitators. Some students, however, insist that teacher-centered instruction is the more successful approach. Most of the time, I believe it is better for teachers to combine several strategies in order to meet all of the demands of their students.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

THINK PAIR SHARING

Think-pair-share: what is it? You should implement it as a teaching approach in the classroom! Here, I'll go over all you need to know about think-pair-share, including its purpose, advantages, potential drawbacks, and how to use it in your classroom. The think-pair-share method gives students time for personal reflection, thinking, and information processing before they might be swayed by other students' responses. Through this procedure, students learn how to articulate their ideas first to a peer and later to a wider group of people (the entire class). How Should We Apply Think-Pair-Share? Before starting the exercise, go over the technique with the students. Describe the goal, establish the parameters and time constraints for the discussion, and demonstrate the technique to make sure the students understand it. Step 1: Think Start by asking a specific question. Then, give each student time to consider their own response and record it independently, either in writing or with...

Which is good? Teacher Centric or Student Centric classrooms?

When deciding how to approach your strategy of imparting knowledge as a teacher, you want to choose a strategy that is useful to all of your learners. You want your students to enjoy the learning process while still keeping your classroom orderly and regulated. I don't think I am wrong if I say that you've definitely come across a dispute that has been at the forefront of educators' minds- is teacher-centered education better than student-centered education? To assist you decide which is best for you, I have tried to explain both teacher-centered education and student-centered education and compiled what has been offered as the merits and cons of each. Methods of instructions delivered in a classroom can either be student centered or teacher centered. Let's talk about both of these teaching methods in this session- its benefits and drawbacks. After interacting with a lot of parents during my tenure as a Principal, I got to know a fact that prevailed in my locality. The ...

Recognize the thought process in children

I hope you have got a glimpse of the concept of cognitive biases and it's impact that we discussed in our previous session. Let me tell you - A large component of critical thinking is simply avoiding cognitive biases. A student in sixth grade once asked me a doubt during my Physics class while I was explaining about the topic Universe. The question was why the randomly scattered pieces from a primitive fireball were spherical in shape. Before this question arose, I had explained to the class that all planets were scattered by a fireball that we named the Sun and the scattered parts revolved around the Sun. When the doubt was asked to me, I was first baffled by the sixth-grader's query, but managed to convince the class sooner by my explanation about gravity. I could explain the fact that a planet's gravity pulls equally from all sides. After the class I quickly decided against looking too deeply into that question, probably how could a child arrive at such an imagination. M...